Unique Jewelry Gifts

Unique Gifts

Filter
180 products
FeaturedBest sellingAlphabetically, A-ZAlphabetically, Z-APrice, low to highPrice, high to lowDate, old to newDate, new to old
Filters

Filter

PRODUCT TYPE

INVENTORY

Price Range

Color

MATERIAL

Metal

clear

METAL FINISH

Ring Width

RING PROFILE

SETTING STYLE

STONE TYPE

STONE SHAPE

Collection

clear
Product Type
Price
$
$
Gemstone
Sort by
Diamond Crisscross Heart Promise Ring
From $135.00
Sterling Silver
Diamond Crisscross Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072419 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Diamond Crisscross Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072419 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Diamond Crisscross Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072419 - Jewelry by Johan
Dazzling Diamond Heart Promise Ring
From $129.00
Sterling Silver
Dazzling Diamond Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072455 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Dazzling Diamond Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072455 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Dazzling Diamond Heart Promise Ring-SHRH072455 - Jewelry by Johan
Diamond, Double Heart Stud Earrings
From $105.00
Sterling Silver
Diamond Heart Stud Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF070654ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Diamond Heart Stud Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF070654ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Diamond Heart Stud Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF070654ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Stud Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Stud Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Tiny Rose Gold Stud Earrings
+ 3 more
1/2 CT. T.W. Diamond Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver
From $539.00
Sterling Silver
1/2 CT. T.W. Diamond Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
1/2 CT. T.W. Diamond Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
1/2 CT. T.W. Diamond Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver - Jewelry by Johan
Black Diamond Circle Stud Earrings
From $289.00
Sterling Silver
Black Diamond Circle Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver-SHEW201881 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Black Diamond Circle Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver-SHEW201881 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Black Diamond Circle Stud Earrings, White Gold or Silver-SHEW201881 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Black Diamond Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Black Diamond Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Black Diamond Rose Gold Earrings
+ 3 more
Black Diamond Triangle Stud Earrings
From $205.00
14k Rose Gold
Black Diamond Triangle Stud Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHES202302 - Jewelry by Johan
 Sterling Silver
Black Diamond Triangle Stud Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHES202302 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Black Diamond Triangle Stud Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHES202302 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Black Diamond Earrings
+ 1 more
Black Diamond Heart Earrings, Rose Gold or Silver
From $215.00
14k Rose Gold
Black Diamond Heart Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHEH201256 - Jewelry by Johan
 Sterling Silver
Black Diamond Heart Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHEH201256 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Black Diamond Heart Earrings, Pink Gold or Silver-SHEH201256 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Heart Earrings With Black Diamonds
+ 1 more
Moldavite Star Stud Earrings In Yellow, White or Rose Gold-4650ML
$395.00
14k Yellow Gold
Moldavite Star Stud Earrings In Yellow, White or Rose Gold-4650ML - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Moldavite Star Stud Earrings In Yellow, White or Rose Gold-4650ML - Jewelry by Johan
 14k Rose Gold
Moldavite Star Stud Earrings In Yellow, White or Rose Gold-4650ML - Jewelry by Johan
Reversible Diamond Circle Necklace, Black & White Diamonds
From $315.00
Sterling Silver
Reversible Diamond Circle Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHNW203014 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Reversible Diamond Circle Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHNW203014 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Reversible Diamond Circle Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHNW203014 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Circle Necklace
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Circle Necklace
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold DIamond Circle Necklace
+ 3 more
Black Diamond Butterfly Necklace, Silver or White Gold
From $219.00
Sterling Silver
Black Diamond Butterfly Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF077198 - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Black Diamond Butterfly Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF077198 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Black Diamond Butterfly Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF077198 - Jewelry by Johan
Solid Gold Cross Pendant with Wood Inlay
In Stock
$905.00 $1,429.00
Swirly Diamond Heart Necklace
From $89.00
14k Rose Gold
Swirly Diamond Heart Necklace, Rose Gold or Silver-SHPH073074ATP - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Swirly Diamond Heart Necklace, Rose Gold or Silver-SHPH073074ATP - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Swirly Diamond Heart Necklace, Rose Gold or Silver-SHPH073074ATP - Jewelry by Johan
 Sterling Silver
Swirly Diamond Heart Necklace, Rose Gold or Silver-SHPH073074ATP - Jewelry by Johan
+ 1 more
Lucky Horseshoe Diamond Necklace
From $285.00
10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold & Diamond Horseshoe Necklace
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold & Diamond Horseshoe Necklace
 14k Rose Gold
Roe Gold & Diamond Horseshoe Necklace
 10k White Gold
Lucky Horseshoe Diamond Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPFG25239 - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Lucky Horseshoe Diamond Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPFG25239 - Jewelry by Johan
 Sterling Silver
Lucky Horseshoe Diamond Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPFG25239 - Jewelry by Johan
+ 3 more
White & Black Diamond Infinity Necklace
From $209.00
10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Black Diamond Necklace
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Black Diamond Necklace
 10k White Gold
White & Black Diamond Infinity Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073356CAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
White & Black Diamond Infinity Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073356CAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Black and White Diamond Necklace
 Sterling Silver
White & Black Diamond Infinity Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073356CAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
+ 3 more
Double Heart Infinity Diamond Necklace
From $105.00
Sterling Silver
Double Heart Infinity Diamond Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073170ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Double Heart Infinity Diamond Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073170ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Double Heart Infinity Diamond Necklace, Silver or Gold-SHPF073170ATW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Gold Double Heart & Infinity Necklace
 14k Yellow Gold
Gold Double Heart & Infinity Necklace
 14k Rose Gold
Gold Double Heart & Infinity Necklace
+ 3 more
Diamond Cluster Necklace With Twist Design
From $195.00
Sterling Silver
Diamond Cluster Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF016386BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Diamond Cluster Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF016386BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Diamond Cluster Necklace, Silver or White Gold-SHPF016386BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Diamond Necklace With Twist Style
 14k Yellow Gold
Diamond Necklace With Twist Style
 14K Rose Gold
Twisting Necklace With Diamond Cluster
+ 3 more
Diamond Twist Dangle Statement Earrings
From $225.00
Sterling Silver
Diamond Twist Dangle Statement Earrings-SHEH014871CTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Diamond Twist Dangle Statement Earrings-SHEH014871CTW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Diamond Twist Dangle Statement Earrings-SHEH014871CTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Unique Yellow Gold & Diamond Dangle Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Unique Yellow Gold & Diamond Dangle Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Unique Rose Gold & Diamond Dangle Earrings
+ 3 more
Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings, Silver or Gold
From $269.00
Sterling Silver
Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings, Silver or Gold - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings, Silver or Gold - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Diamond Cluster Stud Earrings, Silver or Gold - Jewelry by Johan
Unique Diamond Two Tone Drop Earrings
From $225.00
Sterling Silver
Unique Diamond Two Tone Drop Earrings - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Rose Gold
Unique Diamond Two Tone Drop Earrings - Jewelry by Johan
 14k Rose Gold
Unique Diamond Two Tone Drop Earrings - Jewelry by Johan
Infinity Heart Diamond Dangle Earrings
From $149.00
Sterling Silver
Infinity Heart Diamond Dangle Earrings-SHEF073833BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Infinity Heart Diamond Dangle Earrings-SHEF073833BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Infinity Heart Diamond Dangle Earrings-SHEF073833BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold DIamond Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold DIamond Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Earrings
+ 3 more
Diamond Infinity Knot Drop Earrings
From $195.00
10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Infinity Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Infinity Earrings
 10k White Gold
Diamond Infinity Knot Drop Earrings
 14k White Gold
Diamond Infinity Knot Drop Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Diamond Infinity Knot Drop Earrings
 Sterling Silver
Diamond Infinity Knot Drop Earrings
+ 3 more
Tiered Dangle Earrings With Diamonds
From $165.00
Sterling Silver
Tiered Dangle Earrings With Diamonds, Silver or Gold-SHEF016402BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Tiered Dangle Earrings With Diamonds, Silver or Gold-SHEF016402BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Tiered Dangle Earrings With Diamonds, Silver or Gold-SHEF016402BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Cluster Earrings
+ 3 more
Drop Diamond Earrings With Twisting Design
From $165.00
Sterling Silver
Drop Diamond Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF015040BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Drop Diamond Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF015040BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Drop Diamond Earrings, Silver or White Gold-SHEF015040BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Accented Dangle Earrings
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Accented Dangle Earrings
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Accented Dangle Earrings
+ 3 more
Unique Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
From $435.00
Sterling Silver
White Gold Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
 10k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
 14k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Infinity Diamond Bracelet
+ 3 more
Diamond Heart Chain Link Bracelet
From $225.00
Sterling Silver
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
 10k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
 14k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Bracelet With Heart Chain
+ 3 more
1 Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet
From $1,259.00
Sterling Silver
1 Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBT070065KAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
1 Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBT070065KAW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
1 Carat Diamond Tennis Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBT070065KAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Simple Yellow Gold Diamond Tennis Bracelet
 14k Yellow Gold
Simple Yellow Gold Diamond Tennis Bracelet
 14k Rose Gold
Simple Rose Gold Diamond Tennis Bracelet
+ 3 more
Unique Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
From $179.00
Sterling Silver
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
 10k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
 14k White Gold
White Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Bracelet With Infinity Symbols
+ 3 more
Dainty Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet
From $225.00
10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Infinity Bracelet
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Diamond Infinity Bracelet
 14k Rose Gold
Diamond Infinity Bracelet
 Sterling Silver
Dainty Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet-SHBF0024358BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Dainty Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet-SHBF0024358BTW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Dainty Diamond Infinity Symbol Bracelet-SHBF0024358BTW - Jewelry by Johan
+ 3 more
Interlocking Diamond Heart Bracelet
From $195.00
Sterling Silver
Silver Heart & DIamond Bracelet
 10k White Gold
Silver Heart & DIamond Bracelet
 14k White Gold
Silver Heart & DIamond Bracelet
 10k Yellow Gold
YEllow Gold Diamond Heart Bracelet
 14k Yellow Gold
YEllow Gold Diamond Heart Bracelet
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Diamond Heart Bracelet
+ 3 more
Diamond Heart Infinity Bracelet
From $345.00
14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Heart Bracelet With Black & White Diamonds
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Heart Bracelet With Black & White Diamonds
 14k White Gold
Diamond Heart Infinity Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBF072475EAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Heart Bracelet With Black & White Diamonds
 10k White Gold
Diamond Heart Infinity Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBF072475EAW - Jewelry by Johan
 Sterling Silver
Diamond Heart Infinity Bracelet, Silver or White Gold-SHBF072475EAW - Jewelry by Johan
+ 3 more
Tiny Heart Diamond Bracelet
From $209.00
Sterling Silver
Tiny Heart Diamond Bracelet, Sterling Silver or Gold-SHBF070727BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Tiny Heart Diamond Bracelet, Sterling Silver or Gold-SHBF070727BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Tiny Heart Diamond Bracelet, Sterling Silver or Gold-SHBF070727BAW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Heart & DIamond Bracelet
 14k Yellow Gold
Yellow Gold Heart & DIamond Bracelet
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold Heart & Diamond Bracelet
+ 3 more
Black Diamond Infinity Bracelet
From $209.00
10k Yellow Gold
Gold DIamond Bracelet With Tiny Bows or Dog Bones
 14k Yellow Gold
Gold DIamond Bracelet With Tiny Bows or Dog Bones
 14k Rose Gold
Rose Gold DIamond Bracelet With Tiny Bows or Dog Bones
 Sterling Silver
Black Diamond Infinity Bracelet-SHBF074551BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 10k White Gold
Black Diamond Infinity Bracelet-SHBF074551BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
 14k White Gold
Black Diamond Infinity Bracelet-SHBF074551BAWBW - Jewelry by Johan
+ 3 more

Looking for unique jewelry gifts? You're in the right place! All of our jewelry are handcrafted and we've got made to order gifts for every special holiday and event and in stock gifts that ship to you in just 1-3 business days.